A follow-up
Previously, I posted about Kaavya Viswathan, who supposedly unintentionally plagiarized two other novels when writing her book "How Opal Metha Got Kissed, Got Wild, and Got a Life." I was curious what had happened with this story, so I googled her name. It appears that she is now in Wikipedia (a free encyclopedia offered in ten languages and a great source of information on the web) and the plot has thickened. It seems, according to her Wikipeadia entry that she also borrowed from other sources as well, including Can You Keep a Secret? by Sophie Kinsella and Meg Cabot's 2000 novel The Princess Diaries. The similarities are less pronounced, but definitely there.
This made me think of the writer Christopher Paolini who also managed to publish Eragon, a very successful book, and it's sequel, Eldest, at a young age. So, I googled him as well and found his story quite different from Kaavya's. He lives with his parents in Montana where he was homeschooled and where he decided to write the story of Eragon. He took a year writing the first draft, then another year revising it and a third year polishing it even further and finally self-publishing it with the help of his parents.
They then began promoting the book themselves, making appearances at high schools and convincing libraries to carry it. Luckily, Carl Hiaasen (a well known young adult novelist) discovered Eragon and brought it Knopf who then published the book. I really like this story. It shows that hard work, and putting your heart into something you believe in pays off.
In Kaavya's case she had no manuscript she had worked on for several years. She was just given a large sum of money and along with it a lot of pressure to perform. In the end, she probably could find no way out of her mess but to copy here and there and hope for the best.
She was just told, "go and write" which for anyone who writes knows how hard that can be. And then add to it the fact that what she wrote had to be excellent to justify the thousands (and those were LOTS of thousands) she was getting for it. I must admit, if I was faced with that, at eighteen or even now, I would panic too.
I am not pardoning her for what she did, but I am being sympathetic to the fact that she was way way way in over her head. And now, she has been immortalized in Wikipedia for life as the girl who cheated. Not the best way to start your writing career (or any career for that matter).
This made me think of the writer Christopher Paolini who also managed to publish Eragon, a very successful book, and it's sequel, Eldest, at a young age. So, I googled him as well and found his story quite different from Kaavya's. He lives with his parents in Montana where he was homeschooled and where he decided to write the story of Eragon. He took a year writing the first draft, then another year revising it and a third year polishing it even further and finally self-publishing it with the help of his parents.
They then began promoting the book themselves, making appearances at high schools and convincing libraries to carry it. Luckily, Carl Hiaasen (a well known young adult novelist) discovered Eragon and brought it Knopf who then published the book. I really like this story. It shows that hard work, and putting your heart into something you believe in pays off.
In Kaavya's case she had no manuscript she had worked on for several years. She was just given a large sum of money and along with it a lot of pressure to perform. In the end, she probably could find no way out of her mess but to copy here and there and hope for the best.
She was just told, "go and write" which for anyone who writes knows how hard that can be. And then add to it the fact that what she wrote had to be excellent to justify the thousands (and those were LOTS of thousands) she was getting for it. I must admit, if I was faced with that, at eighteen or even now, I would panic too.
I am not pardoning her for what she did, but I am being sympathetic to the fact that she was way way way in over her head. And now, she has been immortalized in Wikipedia for life as the girl who cheated. Not the best way to start your writing career (or any career for that matter).